Home › Island News › Local News
Marco Police Chief Carr wants officers out of their cars
Thom Carr shares his vision at first public speaking engagement as Marco’s top cop
KELLY FARRELL / Staff
Marco Island's new police chief, Thom Carr has his first public appearance as guest speaker at the Marco Police Chief luncheon Wednesday. Marco Police Foundation President Dick Shannahan, Police Chief Thom Carr, Police Foundation Secretary Debra Sanders and Foundation Vice President Bernardo Bezos share the head table at the event.
KELLY FARRELL / Staff
Marco Island Police Chief Thom Carr expresses gratitude to one of the founders of the Marco Police Foundation, Harold Kendall, 87. Carr also thanked the entire Foundation for their support of his quest to become chief while he spoke at the Esplanade's Bayview Restaurant Wednesday.
STORY TOOLS
Tell us about it
- What would you add to this story? Tell us what we missed.
- Do you have photos from this event? Documents we need to see? Share with us.
- Upload photos & videos
- More ways to get your stuff online and in the paper.
RELATED STORIES
- Carr selected as Marco Island's police chief
- Marco Police Foundation bids chief farewell as he goes to Naples
More Local News
- Marco Island to keep City Manager
- Bryan Milk named City of Marco Island Parks and Recreation Director
- Merchants pulling out all the stops to encourage Islanders to shop local
Share and Enjoy [?]
MARCO ISLAND While many people have gotten to know and hear from Thom Carr over his last 10 years with the Marco Island Police Department, the public heard him speak for the first time as chief this week at the Marco Island Police Foundation lunch Wednesday.
City Manager Steve Thompson selected Carr as chief on Aug. 4.
Carr said tropical storm Fay and staffing issues have kept him busy the last three weeks and he was pleased to have the opportunity to address the community publicly for the first time as chief Wednesday.
The Marco Police Foundation endorsed Carr, encouraging Thompson to select the former police captain. Carr took over as acting chief when former Police Chief Roger Reinke left for the position of City of Naples assistant manager in Spring.
“I can’t believe how much this guy has done. Now we know how (Carr) was picked out of over 225 guys,” said Dick Shannan, president of the police foundation as he introduced Carr at the Esplanade’s Bayview Restaurant.
Carr’s experience includes six years of active duty in the U.S. Army, one year of service in Vietnam, CH-47 Chinook helicopter flight, graduation from the FBI National Academy and 36 years of experience in law enforcement beginning with the Indianapolis Police Department.
“Obviously his qualifications are outstanding. There isn’t an inch of space on the wall in his office for another commendation,” said Ken Kubat, treasurer of the police foundation.
Carr began with a humble line as he addressed an audience of about 60 people, including former city councilor Mike Minozzi and current City Councilors Wayne Waldack and Jerry Gibson.
“Some times I reflect on (being chosen out of 250 candidates) and I can’t believe it either,” Carr began.
He thanked the foundation for their “avid support” in his quest to become chief.
Carr said since becoming chief the most frequently asked question concerns the changes he plans to make in the department.
To that, Carr replies: “Will there be wholesale changes? No. Changes in philosophy? Yes.”
The changes will include a shift in the role of the police officer to focus on community needs not just enforcing laws, he said.
“I’d like to get the guys out of their cars a little more, talk to the businesses. Socialize a little more,” he explained of his plan to increase community policing.
Another change will be increased support and promotion of police officers within the department. This process has already begun. When Carr was promoted to chief, it allowed for mobility throughout the department.
He invited the public to attend a promotion ceremony 7 p.m., Friday, at the Community Room next door to the police department 51 Bald Eagle Drive.
The ceremony will congratulate the promotion of three officers and the hiring of one more lieutenant. Marco Lt. Dave Baer will be taking Carr’s prior position as captain, the second in command. Officer Pete Beucler will become a street lieutenant.
Patrolman George Williams, a retiree from the Ohio Highway Patrol, will be promoted to corporal.
Carr said he changed the selection process by bringing in outside agencies, the Florida Highway Patrol and Fish and Wildlife Commission, to assist in interviewing.
“It adds the look and feel of fairness. They will assist in looking at qualifications rather than friendships and that’s what we wanted,” Carr said.
Baer said choosing to promote Carr rather than hire a chief from outside the department may “benefit the community in ways a lot of people may not have even thought of.”
The promotion saves the time and resources that would be necessary to acclimate a new chief to the city and the department, he explained.
Jose Granda, a member of the police foundation and chairman of the code enforcement board, said he was pleased with Carr’s ideas for change.
“To (Carr), it’s a matter of being a part of the community not just having a job ... He wants to get closer to the people, support and promote the officers. I fully support every change he’s mentioned. They’ve been a long time coming,” Granda said.
As to the support the Marco Police Foundation and community showed for Carr’s quest to become chief, Carr said: “I’ll pay you back. I promise.”

Comments
This site does not necessarily agree with comments posted below — responsibility lies with the relevant reader alone. Read our privacy policy & user agreement.
I HOPE THEY GET LITTLE CUTE OUTFITS LIKE THE GUY ON RENO 911
#1 Posted by happyonmarco on August 28, 2008 at 11:26 p.m. (Suggest removal)
Carr's a good man. Thompson is heading in the right direction. We've got some good times ahead of us.
#2 Posted by yes on August 29, 2008 at 7:48 a.m. (Suggest removal)
Are Wayne and Jerry Dating? They always seem to show up together?????
#3 Posted by OldMarcoMan on August 29, 2008 at 5:05 p.m. (Suggest removal)
If the Chief means what he says, why are their 2 and sometimes 3 patrol cars on San Marco Rd. by Vintage Bay sitting there for hours? How many businesses are there to interact with? This is an every day occurrence. I doubt that are many more patrol cars on the road at that time so almost all the patrol force is in one place sitting door to door talking not patroling or interacting. Talk is cheap, lets see some action.
#4 Posted by JohninMarco on August 29, 2008 at 7:01 p.m. (Suggest removal)
Exaggeration is cheaper. Let me guess you sit there for "hours" and watch "them"? Right... It's called traffic enforcement; I've seen them (usually one) there too...just like CCSO used to do as well. I know they hide there so I slow down, we both win. If people didn't speed, the cops probably wouldn't have to sit there and stop cars, or would you prefer that they just report to the speed related accidents after they occurred? I have seen them run speed traps all over the island - Collier Bridge, the highway in front of the Marriott, in the school zone. Leave 'em alone they are trying to a tough job, and they are doing a good job of it.
#5 Posted by B4 on August 30, 2008 at 11:06 a.m. (Suggest removal)
Look at the picture and someone tell me what he's doing with his right hand. The guy in the gray sports jacket seems to be enjoying it.
#6 Posted by hourigan82247 on August 31, 2008 at 7:03 p.m. (Suggest removal)
Support Our New Chief!!
Forget the 250 applicants, Naples had only 125? The reason, posted qualifications, far to broad for the position, that's the answer.
This man was choosen because he has been at Marco from the outset, has proven to be a dedicated and hard working employee and has been loyal to this city! He's is likely be a little differant, less faness and avoidance, more brash and stieght forward, good qualities if people are not overly sensitive.
He's out of the starting blocks in good fashion and is making effective decisions. The recent elevation of the above employess indicates that he too is following the guidelines that allowed him to prevail in the selection process.Undeniably, marco Island must hire many that are, or were not qualified for a large police agency.This is not necessarily bad, however good management can produce a very good employee product given the Marco island Community dynamic.
It's up to them now, so let's do our part and get behind the new team.
#7 Posted by August8 on September 2, 2008 at 8:49 a.m. (Suggest removal)
Diazk: An analysis of your previous posts demonstrates a consistently venomous and odious outlook of law enforcement in general. While you attempt to demonstrate competency, your knowledge and comprehension of law enforcement methods is obviously wanting. Thus I will tutor you. One common tactic is call crime prevention. There are many sub-techniques, however most involve visibility. The Police obviously seek to prevent crime, fights, injuries, thefts, littering, and DUI by being at local saloons periodically while they are open and at closing time as well. This procedure is neither avant guarde nor confined to Marco Island, and has withstood the test of time. Secondly, these providers of sprits pay taxes, and desire moreover deserve the same community policing services (yet another technique) that Burger King or 7-11 enjoy. Chief (not Cheif) Carr’s job does not solely revolve around pleasing you, as the needs of the many outweigh the needs of a few. He is tasked with crime prevention and criminal apprehension, thus he must deploy his officers with these missions in mind. Lastly, if your complaint is synonymous with John’s in that “dozens of cops are there for hours” then we would be in agreement, as this would be wasteful and unnecessary. But we both know that isn’t happening either. If you can find a police handbook that states the contrary to anything I have stated please cite it, otherwise your uneducated opinion is just that. I challenge you to prove my initial assessment of you wrong. Let’s start seeing some insightful and accurate law enforcement related posts from you instead of the usual “I don’t like the cops for whatever reason” posts, like Chicken Little you plaintiff cries are wearing thin.
#8 Posted by B4 on September 3, 2008 at 5:36 a.m. (Suggest removal)
Post your comment
(Requires free registration.)